+1-888-741-7503
NO FEES UNTIL WE WIN
FREE CONSULTATION
NO FEES UNTIL WE WIN
FREE CONSULTATION
You trusted your stockbroker with your life savings. Each month, your account statements arrive packed with trades you never authorized, fees you never expected, and a portfolio value that keeps shrinking. If this sounds familiar, your broker may be churning your account, and you have legal options to recover your losses.
Contact The Frankowski Firm today for a free consultation about your churning claim.
Stockbroker churning is one of the most damaging forms of broker misconduct. It happens when a broker executes excessive trades in your account primarily to generate commissions for themselves, not to benefit you. According to FINRA, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority files disciplinary actions against brokers who excessively trade customer accounts every year. Yet many investors do not realize it is happening until significant damage has been done.
This guide explains what stockbroker churning is, how to spot the warning signs in your account, the financial metrics used to prove churning, and how to pursue a FINRA arbitration claim to recover your losses.
Churning occurs when a stockbroker engages in excessive buying and selling of securities in a customer’s account without considering the customer’s investment goals, primarily to generate commissions that benefit the broker. The SEC defines churning as an illegal practice that violates federal securities laws and FINRA rules.
Three elements must be present for churning to occur:
Churning can happen in any type of brokerage account, including retirement accounts like IRAs and 401(k) rollovers, taxable investment accounts, and trust accounts. Conservative investors and retirees who rely on their portfolios for income are especially vulnerable because their accounts should typically have low trading activity.
Detecting churning early can save you thousands of dollars in unnecessary losses and fees. Watch for these warning signs:
If you see transactions on your account statements that you did not request or approve, this is a serious red flag. While brokers with discretionary authority can make trades without your prior approval, those trades must still align with your stated investment objectives. Frequent unauthorized trades, especially in securities you do not recognize, suggest your broker is prioritizing their commission income over your financial goals.
One of the most telltale signs of churning is a pattern of buying securities and then selling them shortly after, only to reinvest the proceeds in new securities. This “in-and-out” trading pattern generates commissions on every buy and sell transaction while providing no meaningful benefit to your portfolio. FINRA specifically identifies this pattern as a key indicator of excessive trading.
If your broker is making frequent trades but your account balance keeps dropping, the trading costs may be consuming your returns. A legitimate investment strategy should aim to grow your wealth over time. When your portfolio loses value while your broker earns commissions on every trade, the trading is likely benefiting your broker, not you.
Review your account statements for the total commissions and transaction fees charged each quarter. If these costs represent a large percentage of your account value, your broker may be overtrading. Ask your broker to provide a clear breakdown of all fees. If they cannot explain why each trade was necessary for your investment objectives, this is a warning sign.
A broker who discourages you from closely reviewing your account statements, tells you not to worry about the details, or encourages you to ignore trade confirmations may be trying to hide excessive trading activity. Every investor has the right to understand what is happening in their account, and any broker who suggests otherwise is not acting in your interest.
If your broker repeatedly moves your money from one mutual fund to another similar mutual fund, or sells bonds only to purchase nearly identical bonds, this “switching” behavior may be churning. Each switch generates a new commission without meaningfully changing your investment position. Legitimate rebalancing should be infrequent and based on changes in your financial situation or market conditions, not on a monthly or quarterly cycle.
When you opened your brokerage account, you completed a new account form documenting your risk tolerance, investment experience, income, net worth, and time horizon. If your account shows aggressive, high-frequency trading but your profile indicates you are a conservative investor seeking income or capital preservation, the mismatch between your profile and your trading activity is strong evidence of churning. This is particularly common in accounts belonging to retirees, elderly investors, and individuals who are new to investing.
Securities regulators and securities arbitration attorneys use specific quantitative metrics to prove that trading in an account was excessive. Understanding these numbers can help you evaluate whether your account has been churned.
The turnover ratio measures how many times the total equity in your account is bought and sold over a 12-month period. It is calculated by dividing the total cost of all purchases during the year by the average monthly equity in the account.
FINRA and the courts generally consider the following thresholds:
For conservative accounts, even a turnover ratio as low as 2 may be considered excessive, depending on the investor’s stated objectives and risk tolerance.
Also called the “break-even” or “commission-to-equity” ratio, this metric calculates the annualized percentage return your account must earn just to cover the commissions and fees being charged. It is calculated by dividing the total commissions and costs by the average account equity, then annualizing the result.
A cost-to-equity ratio above 5% is generally considered a red flag for excessive costs. In many churning cases, this ratio can reach 15% to 25% or higher, meaning your account would need to earn 15% to 25% annually just to break even after paying your broker’s commissions.
The financial damage caused by stockbroker churning extends far beyond the commissions you pay. Churning creates a cascade of losses that can devastate your financial security:
While churning can happen to any investor, certain groups are particularly vulnerable:
If you believe your account has been churned, you can file a claim through FINRA arbitration, the primary forum for resolving disputes between investors and their brokerage firms. To succeed in a churning claim, you and your attorney must establish three key elements:
You must show that your broker exercised control over the trading decisions in your account. This can be established through formal discretionary authority, where you signed an agreement giving your broker permission to trade without consulting you first. It can also be shown through de facto control, where the evidence demonstrates your broker effectively controlled the trading activity because you routinely followed their recommendations without independently evaluating each trade. FINRA arbitration panels frequently find de facto control when the broker made all the recommendations and the customer simply approved them.
The turnover ratio, cost-to-equity ratio, and in-and-out trading patterns discussed above serve as quantitative evidence of excessive trading. Your attorney will analyze your account records to calculate these metrics and compare them against established thresholds.
Scienter refers to the broker’s intent or reckless disregard for your interests. While direct proof of a broker’s mental state is rare, the quantitative evidence of excessive trading itself can support an inference of scienter. FINRA arbitration panels recognize that a broker who generates a turnover ratio of 6 or higher knew, or should have known, that the trading was not in the customer’s interest. Evidence of the broker’s commission income relative to their total production can further strengthen this element.
If your churning claim is successful, you may be able to recover several types of damages:
Proving churning requires a deep understanding of securities regulations, FINRA rules, and the quantitative analysis used to demonstrate excessive trading. Richard Frankowski and The Frankowski Firm have over 25 years of experience representing investors in FINRA arbitration proceedings involving churning and other forms of broker misconduct.
As a member of the Board of Directors of the PIABA Foundation (Public Investors Advocate Bar Association), Richard Frankowski is actively involved in advocating for stronger investor protections at the national level. The Frankowski Firm handles cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless the firm recovers money for you.
Your attorney can obtain your complete account records from your brokerage firm, perform a detailed analysis of trading activity, turnover ratios, and cost-to-equity metrics, identify patterns of unsuitable recommendations beyond just churning, and represent you before a FINRA arbitration panel composed of experienced securities professionals.
The clearest indicators are a high volume of trades you did not initiate, declining account values despite active trading, commissions that represent a large percentage of your account equity, and frequent “in-and-out” buying and selling of securities. Calculate your turnover ratio by dividing total purchases by average monthly equity. A ratio above 4 is generally presumed excessive.
FINRA arbitration claims must generally be filed within six years of the events giving rise to the dispute. However, some claims may also be subject to shorter state statutes of limitations. Because churning often occurs over an extended period, the timeline can be complex. Consult an attorney as soon as you suspect churning to preserve your rights.
While churning is most commonly associated with commission-based accounts, excessive trading can also harm investors in fee-based accounts. In a fee-based or wrap-fee account, the harm may come from a breach of fiduciary duty through reverse churning (too little trading for the fee charged) or through unsuitable, high-frequency trading that generates losses even without additional commissions.
First, request copies of all your account statements and trade confirmations from your brokerage firm. Second, do not authorize any additional trades until you have consulted with a securities attorney. Third, file a written complaint with your brokerage firm’s compliance department. Fourth, contact an attorney who handles FINRA arbitration claims to review your account records and advise you on your options.
The Frankowski Firm handles churning claims on a contingency fee basis, which means you pay no upfront legal fees. The firm is only compensated if it successfully recovers money for you. FINRA filing fees are based on the amount of damages claimed and typically range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars.
Stockbroker churning is illegal, and you have the right to recover your losses. If you recognize any of the warning signs described in this guide, do not wait. The sooner you take action, the more effectively an attorney can document the excessive trading and build a strong case for your FINRA arbitration claim.
Contact The Frankowski Firm today at 888-741-7503 for a free, confidential consultation about your stockbroker churning claim. With over 25 years of experience in securities arbitration, Richard Frankowski and his team will review your account, calculate the key metrics, and help you understand your legal options. You pay nothing unless we recover your losses.